HomeResearch & Knowledgeback to HomeSustainabilityback to Research & KnowledgeFalling from grace: Sulzer and the Dow Jones Sustainability Indexback to Sustainability

Case Study

Falling from grace: Sulzer and the Dow Jones Sustainability Index

By Ulrich Steger and Oliver Salzmann

11 pages

October 2002

Order this case study

Reference: IMD-2-0099

In September 2001, Sulzer AG was dropped from the Dow Jones Sustainability Indexes, which is composed by the Zurich-based SAM Group. SAM justified the removal with a badly managed implant recall at a US subsidiary of Sulzer’s former medical division Sulzer Medica, which Sulzer AG had spun off in July 2001. The case illustrates the challenge of conclusively rating companies’ sustainability performance in complex strategic and/or operational situations, and the dilemma rated companies can face. The complex situation in this case results from Sulzer AG’s significant strategic reorientation to industrial activities, a hostile takeover attempt and the product recall at Sulzer Medica, in which, when the recall was launched, it had a majority interest – with the intention of selling it in the near future. Moreover, the case provokes discussion about internal and external effects of the removal from the index, and adequate reactions of Sulzer AG in the short and long term.

Keywords

Sustainability Ratings, Corporate Governance, Product Recall, Crisis Management, Corporate Sustainability Management

Settings

September 2001

Type

Field Research

Available Languages

English

Related material

Teaching note

IMD case studies are distributed through case clearing houses. In order to browse the collection and purchase copies please visit the links below.

The Case Centre

Cranfield University

Wharley End Beds MK43 0JR, UK
Tel +44 (0)1234 750903
Email [email protected]

Harvard Business School Publishing

60 Harvard Way, Boston MA 02163, USA
Tel (800) 545-7685 Tel (617)-783-7600
Fax (617) 783-7666
Email [email protected]

Asia Pacific Case Center

NUCB Business School

1-3-1 Nishiki Naka
Nagoya Aichi, Japan 460-0003
Tel +81 52 20 38 111
Email [email protected]

IMD retains all proprietary interests in its case studies and notes. Without prior written permission, IMD cases and notes may not be reproduced, used, translated, included in books or other publications, distributed in any form or by any means, stored in a database or in other retrieval systems. For additional copyright information related to case studies, please contact Case Services.

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Keep reading

Article

Navigating Luxury’s New Reality - Krug - Manuel Reman

CEO Manuel Reman blends Krug's tradition with innovation, fostering deeper connections with global audiences and emphasizing authenticity to keep the champagne house relevant amid shifting tastes and sustainability challenges.

Leadership Luxury Strategy Sustainability Innovation

By Stéphane J. G. Girod

in I by IMD

30 January 2025

Article

Soft skills for hard targets: Why leaders need IDGs to reach the SDGs

Progress towards achieving the UN Sustainable Development Goals has been slow. Leaders need Inner Development Goals to become true sustainability champions.

Sustainability Leadership

By David Bach, Natalia Olynec and Heather Cairns-Lee

in I by IMD Brain Circuits

27 January 2025

Case Study

Brookfield Asset Management Catalytic Transition Fund

Finance Economics Sustainability

By Arturo Bris and Raphaël Jean Luigi Grieco

Case Study

Sea2see: Seastainable vision

Entrepreneurship Family Business General Management Global Business Marketing Sustainability

By Benoit F. Leleux and Thomas Brochier

Article

Seeing The Full Picture - Sustainable Prosperity - Davos 2025

Capitalism’s fixation on financial metrics blinds us to the true cost of prosperity, eroding the very foundations of wealth creation. At the opening night of the SDG Tent in Davos, panelists called for a broader definition of value – one that embr...

Business Transformation Sustainability

By Julia Katharina Binder

in I by IMD

21 January 2025

Article

How to become a digital sustainability leader in 5 steps

Companies that excel in both digital and sustainable transformation attract a stock market premium – but how do you tap into that value? Here’s a five-step guide to outperforming your competitors.

Sustainability Digital

By Michael R. Wade and Evangelos Syrigos

in I by IMD Brain Circuits

20 January 2025

Article

Antidote to antibiotic resistance - Knut Haanaes - Carlos Cordon

With millions of lives at risk, resistance to antibiotics is one of the most pressing health challenges of our time. Our ‘Future Back’ approach to problem-solving could help find a cure.

Future Readiness Innovation Sustainability

By Carlos Cordon and Knut Bjarne Haanaes

in I by IMD

20 January 2025

Article

Sustainable Transformation - Strategy - Leadership

By aligning purpose with profit, fostering innovation, and building resilience, companies can turn the challenges of embedding sustainability into their business into opportunities.

Sustainability

By Julia Katharina Binder and Knut Bjarne Haanaes

in I by IMD

17 January 2025

Article

How Natura &Co and other eco-pioneers sowed the seeds of positive change

The Brazilian cosmetics company works with Amazonian communities to promote sustainable business practices. Respecting nature, upholding communities as key stakeholders, addressing social issues, and focusing on results are essential components of...

Sustainability

By Robert Chatwin and Sophie Bacq

in I by IMD

17 January 2025

Article

Business and Science - Partners for sustainability

Science-based approaches to sustainability are on the rise as firms seek to build strategies that align with the planetary boundaries. But how can scientists and businesses see eye to eye?

Sustainability

By Amanda Williams, John N. Parker, Steve Kennedy and Gail Whiteman

in I by IMD

15 January 2025

Navigating Luxury’s New Reality - Krug - Manuel Reman

By Stéphane J. G. Girod
in I by IMD 30 January 2025

Summary

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Leadership

Luxury

Strategy

Sustainability

Innovation

Browse all topics

Soft skills for hard targets: Why leaders need IDGs to reach the SDGs

By David Bach Natalia Olynec and Heather Cairns-Lee
in I by IMD Brain Circuits 27 January 2025

Summary

Progress towards achieving the UN Sustainable Development Goals has been slow. Leaders need Inner Development Goals to become true sustainability champions.

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Sustainability

Leadership

Browse all topics

Brookfield Asset Management Catalytic Transition Fund

By Arturo Bris and Raphaël Jean Luigi Grieco
Case reference: IMD-2652 ©2024

Summary

Brookfield’s Catalytic Transition Fund is a case study in how the financial industry can spearhead sustainable development. Brookfield Asset Management announced an initial closing of $2.4 billion for the Catalytic Transition Fund, marking a significant milestone toward the target of raising up to $5 billion for deployment to clean energy and transition assets in emerging markets. $1 billion of capital was provided by ALTÉRRA, the world’s largest private investment vehicle for climate finance based in the United Arab Emirates, with the purpose of mobilizing investment at scale to finance a new climate economy. The fund is focused on deploying capital into clean energy and transition assets in emerging markets in South and Central America, South and Southeast Asia, the Middle East, and Eastern Europe. This strategic partnership will help drive clean energy investment into emerging markets, where investment needs to increase sixfold over current levels to reach the $1.6 trillion required annually by the early 2030s in line with global net zero targets.

Reference IMD-2652

Organization Brookfield Asset Management

Industry Finance and Insurance, Private Equity

Available Languages English

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Finance

Economics

Sustainability

Browse all topics

Sea2see: Seastainable vision

By Benoit F. Leleux and Thomas Brochier
Case reference: IMD-7-2564 ©2024

Summary

BARCELONA, JANUARY 2023. What started in 2016 as a humble entrepreneurial attempt to contribute to a more sustainable future had turned into a solid eyewear brand present in major Western markets. François van den Abeele was even more excited by the rapid development of the Sea2see Foundation, which he set up in Ghana. But success brought its own new questions and issues. From the start, he had relied on the superb craftmanship and dedication of an Italian frame manufacturer. Over time that relationship had turned into a mutual dependency: He was now one of its major clients but, reciprocally, had developed a key supplier risk. What if something happened to that relationship? Should he develop a broader set of suppliers and, if so, how could that be done without antagonizing a great working relationship? Recycling very much set the stage for the brand’s sustainability claims, but it also took massive amounts of time to manage. As other companies started to develop their own fishing net recycling supply chains, did it still make sense to invest so much time in the upstream phase or should he pour his energy into his beloved brand? Finally, maybe it was also time to revisit the growth/profitability dilemma and open up the capital to increase the speed of growth, all for the benefit of the environment as impact fed on scale.

Reference IMD-7-2564

Organization Sea2see

Industry Consumer Goods, Optical Products

Available Languages English

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Entrepreneurship

Family Business

General Management

Global Business

Marketing

Sustainability

Browse all topics

Seeing The Full Picture - Sustainable Prosperity - Davos 2025

By Julia Katharina Binder
in I by IMD 21 January 2025

Summary

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Business Transformation

Sustainability

Browse all topics

How to become a digital sustainability leader in 5 steps

By Michael R. Wade and Evangelos Syrigos
in I by IMD Brain Circuits 20 January 2025

Summary

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Sustainability

Digital

Browse all topics

Antidote to antibiotic resistance - Knut Haanaes - Carlos Cordon

By Carlos Cordon and Knut Bjarne Haanaes
in I by IMD 20 January 2025

Summary

With millions of lives at risk, resistance to antibiotics is one of the most pressing health challenges of our time. Our ‘Future Back’ approach to problem-solving could help find a cure.

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Future Readiness

Innovation

Sustainability

Browse all topics