Close
    HomeResearch & Knowledgeback to HomeFinanceback to Research & KnowledgeAlliance Boots (A): Too big for his boots? Taking a FTSE 100 company privateback to Finance
    Case Study

    Alliance Boots (A): Too big for his boots? Taking a FTSE 100 company private

    By Stewart Hamilton and Sarah Hutton
    13 pages
    December 2007
    Order this case study
    Reference: IMD-1-0257

    The marriage between Boots the Chemist, the UK’s leading retail pharmacy chain, and Alliance UniChem, one of Europe’s largest drug wholesalers, was declared a match made in heaven by the two main instigators of the deal; Sir Nigel Rudd, chairman of Boots, and Stefano Pessina, executive deputy chairman of Alliance UniChem. The £7 billion merger was said to be a true merger of equals and would form a springboard to turn the company into a global health and beauty care company. Both Rudd and Pessina put an enormous amount of time and effort into convincing their respective shareholders to accept the deal. The campaign paid off and the merged company floated on 31 July 2006. Less than eight months later, Pessina took centre stage again for another announcement. In what was seen as a shocking turnaround by many City observers, not to mention by the Alliance Boots investors, he made a formal bid, backed by the private equity firm Kohlberg Kravis Roberts (KKR), to take the company private. It was not simply the speed of the turnaround that was an issue. Pessina was executive deputy chairman of Alliance Boots, managing the strategy and integration of the merged company. He was also the largest individual shareholder with a 15% stake in the company. To complicate matters further, many of the executive and non-executive board members had previous connections with Pessina, as did some of the advisors involved in the proposed deal; Goldman Sachs, acting for Alliance Boots, was simultaneously advising KKR on another deal; and Alliance Boots and KKR were using the same financial PR firm. It was impossible for investors to know where to turn to get an objective view of the situation. Sir Nigel Rudd, as chairman of the board, had his work cut out for him.

    Learning Objective

    Participants should understand 1) that the stewardship of an independent board by the chairman can sometimes be particularly difficult in certain circumstances yet it remains one of his primary responsibilities; 2) that the resolution of multiple conflicts of interest is often not clear cut; 3) that the goal of maximising shareholder value can involve a number of conflicting options and choices; 4) some of the underlying factors driving the private equity sector.

    Keywords
    Shareholder Value, Private Equity, Takeover Bid, Bidding War, Pharmacy, Pharmaceutical Wholesale
    Settings
    United Kingdom
    2005-2007
    Type
    Published Sources
    Copyright
    © 2007
    Available Languages
    English
    Case clearing houses
    IMD case studies are distributed through case clearing houses. In order to browse the collection and purchase copies please visit the links below.

    The Case Centre

    Cranfield University

    Wharley End Beds MK43 0JR, UK
    Tel +44 (0)1234 750903
    Email [email protected]

    Harvard Business School Publishing

    60 Harvard Way, Boston MA 02163, USA
    Tel (800) 545-7685 Tel (617)-783-7600
    Fax (617) 783-7666
    Email [email protected]

    Asia Pacific Case Center

    NUCB Business School

    1-3-1 Nishiki Naka
    Nagoya Aichi, Japan 460-0003
    Tel +81 52 20 38 111
    Email [email protected]

    Copyright Information

    IMD retains all proprietary interests in its case studies and notes. Without prior written permission, IMD cases and notes may not be reproduced, used, translated, included in books or other publications, distributed in any form or by any means, stored in a database or in other retrieval systems. For additional copyright information related to case studies, please contact Case Services.

    Contact

    Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

    This case study is part of a series
    • Alliance Boots (A): Too big for his boots? Taking a FTSE 100 company private
    • Alliance Boots (B): The winners and losers
    Related topics
    Finance
    Browse all topics
    This case study is part of a series
    • Alliance Boots (A): Too big for his boots? Taking a FTSE 100 company private
    • Alliance Boots (B): The winners and losers
    Discover our latest research
    IMD's faculty and research teams publish articles, case studies, books and reports on a wide range of topics
    All case studies
    Alliance Boots (A): Too big for his boots? Taking a FTSE 100 company private
    By Stewart Hamilton and Sarah Hutton
    Case reference: IMD-1-0257 ©2007
    Summary
    The marriage between Boots the Chemist, the UK’s leading retail pharmacy chain, and Alliance UniChem, one of Europe’s largest drug wholesalers, was declared a match made in heaven by the two main instigators of the deal; Sir Nigel Rudd, chairman of Boots, and Stefano Pessina, executive deputy chairman of Alliance UniChem. The £7 billion merger was said to be a true merger of equals and would form a springboard to turn the company into a global health and beauty care company. Both Rudd and Pessina put an enormous amount of time and effort into convincing their respective shareholders to accept the deal. The campaign paid off and the merged company floated on 31 July 2006. Less than eight months later, Pessina took centre stage again for another announcement. In what was seen as a shocking turnaround by many City observers, not to mention by the Alliance Boots investors, he made a formal bid, backed by the private equity firm Kohlberg Kravis Roberts (KKR), to take the company private. It was not simply the speed of the turnaround that was an issue. Pessina was executive deputy chairman of Alliance Boots, managing the strategy and integration of the merged company. He was also the largest individual shareholder with a 15% stake in the company. To complicate matters further, many of the executive and non-executive board members had previous connections with Pessina, as did some of the advisors involved in the proposed deal; Goldman Sachs, acting for Alliance Boots, was simultaneously advising KKR on another deal; and Alliance Boots and KKR were using the same financial PR firm. It was impossible for investors to know where to turn to get an objective view of the situation. Sir Nigel Rudd, as chairman of the board, had his work cut out for him.
    Reference IMD-1-0257
    Copyright ©2007
    Copyright owner IMD Copyright
    Available Languages English
    Contact

    Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

    Related topics
    Finance
    Browse all topics
    Related content
    Case Study
    Alliance Boots (B): The winners and losers

    The marriage between Boots the Chemist, the UK’s leading retail pharmacy chain, and Alliance UniChem, one of Europe’s largest drug wholesalers, was...

    Finance
    By Stewart Hamilton and Sarah Hutton
    Case reference: IMD-1-0258, © 2007
    Read more
    Alliance Boots (B): The winners and losers
    By Stewart Hamilton and Sarah Hutton
    Case reference: IMD-1-0258 ©2007
    Summary
    The marriage between Boots the Chemist, the UK’s leading retail pharmacy chain, and Alliance UniChem, one of Europe’s largest drug wholesalers, was declared a match made in heaven by the two main instigators of the deal; Sir Nigel Rudd, chairman of Boots, and Stefano Pessina, executive deputy chairman of Alliance UniChem. The £7 billion merger was said to be a true merger of equals and would form a springboard to turn the company into a global health and beauty care company. Both Rudd and Pessina put an enormous amount of time and effort into convincing their respective shareholders to accept the deal. The campaign paid off and the merged company floated on 31 July 2006. Less than eight months later, Pessina took centre stage again for another announcement. In what was seen as a shocking turnaround by many City observers, not to mention by the Alliance Boots investors, he made a formal bid, backed by the private equity firm Kohlberg Kravis Roberts (KKR), to take the company private. It was not simply the speed of the turnaround that was an issue. Pessina was executive deputy chairman of Alliance Boots, managing the strategy and integration of the merged company. He was also the largest individual shareholder with a 15% stake in the company. To complicate matters further, many of the executive and non-executive board members had previous connections with Pessina, as did some of the advisors involved in the proposed deal; Goldman Sachs, acting for Alliance Boots, was simultaneously advising KKR on another deal; and Alliance Boots and KKR were using the same financial PR firm. It was impossible for investors to know where to turn to get an objective view of the situation. Sir Nigel Rudd, as chairman of the board, had his work cut out for him.
    Reference IMD-1-0258
    Copyright ©2007
    Copyright owner IMD Copyright
    Available Languages English
    Contact

    Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

    Related topics
    Finance
    Browse all topics
    Related content
    Case Study
    Alliance Boots (A): Too big for his boots? Taking a FTSE 100 company private

    The marriage between Boots the Chemist, the UK’s leading retail pharmacy chain, and Alliance UniChem, one of Europe’s largest drug wholesalers, was...

    Finance
    By Stewart Hamilton and Sarah Hutton
    Case reference: IMD-1-0257, © 2007
    Read more
    Keep reading
    Article
    Climate Risk - CFO Horizons - Financial Imperative

    CFOs must drive a financially disciplined way to manage environmental and climate risk amid growing push back against sustainability efforts.

    Finance Sustainability
    By Karl Schmedders
    in I by IMD
    Read more
    Article
    The dss+ journey - Buying your way into entrepreneurship

    How a private equity-backed corporate carve-out created a successful, sustainable consulting powerhouse by Benoit Leleux

    Entrepreneurship Finance
    By Benoit F. Leleux
    in I by IMD
    Read more
    Article
    Lifepreneurs - Rethinking the default

    Women’s realities are often overlooked, but lifepreneurs—entrepreneurs innovating from experience—are turning struggles into profit and systemic change.

    Finance Innovation
    By Vanina Farber
    in I by IMD
    Read more
    Article
    Banking Regulations - UBS - Sergio Ermotti

    Switzerland should assess the Credit Suisse collapse before adding more banking regulations, says UBS Group CEO in a talk on Europe's financial future.

    Finance
    By David Bach
    in I by IMD
    Read more
    Article
    AI Adoption - From artificial to actionable - CFO

    CFOs can rethink underperforming AI adoption by focusing on business value, data readiness, and employee buy-in.

    Artificial Intelligence Business Transformation Finance Technology Management
    By José Parra Moyano
    in I by IMD
    Read more
    Article
    Is a US crypto reserve the next Fort Knox or a financial time bomb?

    US President Donald Trump’s full embrace of digital assets has sent shock waves through the cryptocurrency market, driving a price surge while creating both new opportunities and heightened risks for investors and corporations. Last week, Mr Trump...

    Geopolitics Digital Finance
    By José Parra Moyano
    in The National
    7 March 2025
    Read more
    Case Study
    DSS+: Carving out a sustainability consulting leader

    The case examines the entrepreneur-led carve out and buyout of dss+, DuPont’s safety and sustainability consulting division, by Gyrus Capital and dss+ management team. dss+ (formerly “DuPont Sustainable Solutions”) played a pivotal role in high-ri...

    Finance Entrepreneurship Sustainability
    By Benoit F. Leleux, Giorgio Pignalosa, Larissa Margot Bieler, Mojisola Onabanjo Akinkunmi and Nicolas Campodonico
    Case reference: IMD-7-2639, © 2025
    Read more
    Article
    Companies need a first-rate geopolitical radar

    Ten years from now, we’ll know which companies best navigated geopolitics. And the hunt will be on for enduring lessons. Which firms made the smartest adjustments to their global commercial footprint by exiting certain markets, doubling down on ot...

    Geopolitics Finance
    By Simon J. Evenett
    in fDi Intelligence
    4 February 2025
    Read more
    Case Study
    Brookfield Asset Management Catalytic Transition Fund

    Brookfield’s Catalytic Transition Fund is a case study in how the financial industry can spearhead sustainable development. Brookfield Asset Management announced an initial closing of $2.4 billion for the Catalytic Transition Fund, marking a signi...

    Finance Economics Sustainability
    By Arturo Bris and Raphaël Jean Luigi Grieco
    Case reference: IMD-2652, © 2024
    Read more
    Article
    The knowledge bank: an essential guide to venture capital

    Explore top books, websites, and podcasts recommended by IMD expert Jim Pulcrano for anyone venturing into or exploring venture capital, from entrepreneurs to investors.

    Decision Making Economics Entrepreneurship Finance Start-up Venture Capital
    By Jim Pulcrano
    in I by IMD
    Read more
    Climate Risk - CFO Horizons - Financial Imperative
    By Karl Schmedders
    in I by IMD
    Summary
    CFOs must drive a financially disciplined way to manage environmental and climate risk amid growing push back against sustainability efforts.
    Read more
    Contact

    Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

    Related topics
    Finance
    Sustainability
    Browse all topics
    The dss+ journey - Buying your way into entrepreneurship
    By Benoit F. Leleux
    in I by IMD
    Summary
    How a private equity-backed corporate carve-out created a successful, sustainable consulting powerhouse by Benoit Leleux
    Read more
    Contact

    Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

    Related topics
    Entrepreneurship
    Finance
    Browse all topics
    Lifepreneurs - Rethinking the default
    By Vanina Farber
    in I by IMD
    Summary
    Women’s realities are often overlooked, but lifepreneurs—entrepreneurs innovating from experience—are turning struggles into profit and systemic change.
    Read more
    Contact

    Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

    Related topics
    Finance
    Innovation
    Browse all topics
    Banking Regulations - UBS - Sergio Ermotti
    By David Bach
    in I by IMD
    Summary
    Switzerland should assess the Credit Suisse collapse before adding more banking regulations, says UBS Group CEO in a talk on Europe's financial future.
    Read more
    Contact

    Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

    Related topics
    Finance
    Browse all topics
    AI Adoption - From artificial to actionable - CFO
    By José Parra Moyano
    in I by IMD
    Summary
    CFOs can rethink underperforming AI adoption by focusing on business value, data readiness, and employee buy-in.
    Read more
    Contact

    Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

    Related topics
    Artificial Intelligence
    Business Transformation
    Finance
    Technology Management
    Browse all topics
    Is a US crypto reserve the next Fort Knox or a financial time bomb?
    By José Parra Moyano
    in The National 7 March 2025
    Summary
    US President Donald Trump’s full embrace of digital assets has sent shock waves through the cryptocurrency market, driving a price surge while creating both new opportunities and heightened risks for investors and corporations. Last week, Mr Trump...
    Read more
    Contact

    Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

    Related topics
    Geopolitics
    Digital
    Finance
    Browse all topics
    DSS+: Carving out a sustainability consulting leader
    By Benoit F. Leleux Giorgio Pignalosa Larissa Margot Bieler Mojisola Onabanjo Akinkunmi and Nicolas Campodonico
    Case reference: IMD-7-2639 ©2025
    Summary
    The case examines the entrepreneur-led carve out and buyout of dss+, DuPont’s safety and sustainability consulting division, by Gyrus Capital and dss+ management team. dss+ (formerly “DuPont Sustainable Solutions”) played a pivotal role in high-risk industries such as oil, gas, and chemicals, providing critical consulting services at a time when global regulatory pressure on operational safety and sustainability was intensifying. Gyrus Capital, a mid-market private equity specialist, came together with the management team to engineer the buyout, based on the firm’s strong and predictable revenue streams, long-term client relationships and specialized expertise in safety and sustainability consulting. What emerged out of the 2019 transaction was an independent sustainability consulting powerhouse with over 1,500 consultants around the world. By 2024, dss+ was still expanding rapidly in terms of staff and domains of expertise, not to mention geography, and had to respond to quickly evolving external and internal demands, with clients increasingly expected to be served globally on a full range of sustainability-related services. With a strong sense of purpose (saving lives and creating a sustainable future), a potent pitch line (Protect. Transform. Sustain), over 750 clients on 1,800 projects across 41 countries, a global team of 1,500 people and plenty of organic growth across 7 core industries, the company was clearly heading for the stars. Yet, new questions loomed: Was it time to start managing that wild growth, deepening competitive advantages and building functional moats? How would dss+ remain competitive? Was it time to put a few new initiatives on high octane fuel: Leadership? Digital transformation? Global growth? Some totally new ideas?
    Reference IMD-7-2639
    Copyright ©2025
    Copyright owner IMD Copyright
    Organization dss+, Gyrus Capital, Inflexion
    Industry Services, Environmental Services;Healthcare, Health and Medical Services;Services, Public Safety;Business Management Services, Consultancy
    Available Languages English
    Contact

    Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

    Related topics
    Finance
    Entrepreneurship
    Sustainability
    Browse all topics
    Companies need a first-rate geopolitical radar
    By Simon J. Evenett
    in fDi Intelligence 4 February 2025
    Summary
    Ten years from now, we’ll know which companies best navigated geopolitics. And the hunt will be on for enduring lessons. Which firms made the smartest adjustments to their global commercial footprint by exiting certain markets, doubling down on ot...
    Read more
    Contact

    Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

    Related topics
    Geopolitics
    Finance
    Browse all topics
    Brookfield Asset Management Catalytic Transition Fund
    By Arturo Bris and Raphaël Jean Luigi Grieco
    Case reference: IMD-2652 ©2024
    Summary
    Brookfield’s Catalytic Transition Fund is a case study in how the financial industry can spearhead sustainable development. Brookfield Asset Management announced an initial closing of $2.4 billion for the Catalytic Transition Fund, marking a significant milestone toward the target of raising up to $5 billion for deployment to clean energy and transition assets in emerging markets. $1 billion of capital was provided by ALTÉRRA, the world’s largest private investment vehicle for climate finance based in the United Arab Emirates, with the purpose of mobilizing investment at scale to finance a new climate economy. The fund is focused on deploying capital into clean energy and transition assets in emerging markets in South and Central America, South and Southeast Asia, the Middle East, and Eastern Europe. This strategic partnership will help drive clean energy investment into emerging markets, where investment needs to increase sixfold over current levels to reach the $1.6 trillion required annually by the early 2030s in line with global net zero targets.
    Reference IMD-2652
    Copyright ©2024
    Copyright owner IMD Copyright
    Organization Brookfield Asset Management
    Industry Finance and Insurance, Private Equity
    Available Languages English
    Contact

    Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

    Related topics
    Finance
    Economics
    Sustainability
    Browse all topics
    The knowledge bank: an essential guide to venture capital
    By Jim Pulcrano
    in I by IMD
    Summary
    Explore top books, websites, and podcasts recommended by IMD expert Jim Pulcrano for anyone venturing into or exploring venture capital, from entrepreneurs to investors.
    Read more
    Contact

    Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

    Related topics
    Decision Making
    Economics
    Entrepreneurship
    Finance
    Start-up
    Venture Capital
    Browse all topics