HomeResearch & Knowledgeback to HomeMarketingback to Research & KnowledgeValue selling at SKF Service (A): Tough buyer confronts strategyback to Marketing

Case Study

Value selling at SKF Service (A): Tough buyer confronts strategy

By Kamran Kashani and Aimee DuBrule

12 pages

November 2009

Order this case study

Reference: IMD-5-0751

Faced with growing competition and commoditization of its core aftermarket business for industrial bearings, SKF develops a sales tool to document, measure and guarantee its customers financial benefits from the use of its replacement products and related services. The strategy is based on justifying premium unit prices that lead to a lower total cost and an attractive return on investment for the customer. However this strategy is not likely to impress Steelcorp, an important end user of bearings buying upwards of $12 million annually. A new procurement VP is asking suppliers of bearings, including SKF, to submit to on-line reverse auction where the lowest unit price is likely to win big orders. SKF senior management is considering a response to Steelcorp’s invitation which is supported by the company’s distributor but opposed by those inside the company who committed to value selling and total cost pricing. The students are to resolve the dilemma and make a decision whether to participate in the auction or refuse to do so and risk losing potentially big orders during recessionary market conditions.

Learning Objective

The case and its video supplement can be used for the following learning objectives: –Demonstrate the mechanics of value (total cost) pricing and the strategic logic of it; –Show the limitations of value pricing (e.g. in face of procurement strategies targeting reduction in per unit cost of goods purchased); –Illustrate how commoditization can be fought back under certain conditions; –Provide insights on how industrial buying-selling and distribution work and the trends reshaping both; –Practice role play and negotiation with a key customer; –Introduce the concept of reverse auction in industrial procurement.

Keywords

Value Pricing, Industrial Selling, Industrial Distribution, Channel Conflict, Commoditization, Reverse Auction, Industrial Marketing, Key Account Management

Settings

World/global, United States of America
Contemporary

Type

Field Research

Available Languages

English, Spanish

Related material

Video

IMD retains all proprietary interests in its case studies and notes. Without prior written permission, IMD cases and notes may not be reproduced, used, translated, included in books or other publications, distributed in any form or by any means, stored in a database or in other retrieval systems. For additional copyright information related to case studies, please contact Case Services.

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

This case study is part of a series

Value selling at SKF Service (A): Tough buyer confronts strategy
Value selling at SKF Service (B): Facing a tough buyer
Value selling at SKF Service (C): Meeting John Elliot

2014 THE CASE CENTRE AWARD WINNER (Overall Winner)

Best-selling Case Study

This case study is part of a series

Value selling at SKF Service (A): Tough buyer confronts strategy
Value selling at SKF Service (B): Facing a tough buyer
Value selling at SKF Service (C): Meeting John Elliot

Keep reading

Case Study

Metalshub: A steely approach to launching a B2B metal trading platform

Few Business to Business (B2B) marketplaces have succeeded. Metalshub has successfully combined a software platform as a service, with a marketplac...

Business to Business Digital Disruption Economics Operations Strategy

By Didier Bonnet, Geoffrey G. Parker, Charles E. Hutchinson and Lisa Simone Duke

Case Study

Contabilizei: Freeing entrepreneurs from Brazil’s tax complexity

The case focuses on Contabilizei, a Brazilian startup providing online accounting services for small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). The case ...

Entrepreneurship Business to Business Digital Strategy

By Benoit F. Leleux, Diego Dias, Ariella Pfenninger, Daniel Töller and Thomas Villiger

Article

Why Chinese companies are betting big on the Euro 24 tournament

Leading Chinese companies are preparing to take advantage of exposure and opportunities as top sponsors and suppliers to the UEFA EURO 2024 Men’s S...

Competitiveness Innovation Strategy China Future Readiness Marketing

By Mark J. Greeven and Howard H. Yu

in I by IMD

5 June 2024

Article

A marketing playbook for sustainable products

Marketing campaigns for sustainable offerings often fail, leaving businesses with products that do not sell. How can companies reach customers more...

Sustainability Strategy Marketing

By Goutam Challagalla and Frédéric Dalsace

in I by IMD

7 May 2024

Case Study

Nespresso: Strategy reset for growth: The youth market (Abridged)

Nespresso, the global leading brand in portioned coffee, is facing an existential threat. The company’s current market base, which consists primari...

Marketing Strategy Sustainability

By Kamran Kashani and Goutam Challagalla

Article

How AI gives Taobao's one billion customers the personal touch [Video]

Chris Tung is President of Strategic Development at Chinese e-commerce multinational Alibaba Group. He tells Amit Joshi how the company is integrat...

Artificial Intelligence Customer Centricity Marketing

By Amit M. Joshi

in I by IMD

16 April 2024

Case Study

How Fuchs built a future ready China strategy

The case describes the strategic evolution of FUCHS China under the leadership of Zhu Qingping as the company transformed into a vital contributor ...

Global Business China Business to Business

By Mark J. Greeven and Wei Wei

Case Study

How Fuchs drives autonomy at scale to win in a fragmented world

In a world where agility and global foresight are crucial for business survival and growth, the FUCHS case presents a compelling narrative of trans...

China Business to Business Global Business Strategy

By Mark J. Greeven and Wei Wei

Article

How to market sustainable products: Three paths to success

Many companies overestimate customers’ appetite for sustainable products, flooding the market with offerings that don’t sell. The reality is, socia...

Sustainability Global Business Marketing

By Goutam Challagalla and Frédéric Dalsace

in Harvard Business Review

March-April 2024, vol. 102, issue 2, pp. 80-87

Case Study

Thales: Digital sales enablement with ContentFlix

The case explores the efforts of Hamilton Mann, Group VP, Global Digital Marketing & Digital Transformation at Thales, to build a sales enablement ...

Digital Transformation Business to Business Marketing Strategy

By Didier Bonnet, Michael R. Wade and Lisa Simone Duke

Metalshub: A steely approach to launching a B2B metal trading platform

By Didier Bonnet Geoffrey G. Parker Charles E. Hutchinson and Lisa Simone Duke
Case reference: IMD-7-2457 ©2024

Summary

Few Business to Business (B2B) marketplaces have succeeded. Metalshub has successfully combined a software platform as a service, with a marketplace matching supply and demand for raw materials used in the Metals and Mining industries. Through innovative pricing and business models, the company has managed to scale its operations in a short timeframe.

Reference IMD-7-2457

Organization Metalshub

Industry Materials, Metals and Mining

Available Languages English

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Business to Business

Digital

Disruption

Economics

Operations

Strategy

Browse all topics

Contabilizei: Freeing entrepreneurs from Brazil’s tax complexity

By Benoit F. Leleux Diego Dias Ariella Pfenninger Daniel Töller and Thomas Villiger
Case reference: IMD-7-2546 ©2024

Summary

The case focuses on Contabilizei, a Brazilian startup providing online accounting services for small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). The case study delves into the challenges faced by the company’s founder and CEO, Vitor Torres, as he navigated Brazil’s complex social and economic landscape. Issues such as Brazil’s byzantine tax system, disparate educational quality and accessibility, and the high cost of doing business in the country are explored. Despite these barriers, Contabilizei demonstrated impressive growth, transforming digital innovation into standardized services. However, the rise of competitors and persistent profitability concerns prompt Torres to thoroughly explore future strategies to maintain market leadership and improve financial performance. The case provides an in-depth analysis of Brazil’s entrepreneurial ecosystem, examining its business, educational, legal and infrastructural realities and their implications for startups as well as the difficult step for startups to become established companies.

Reference IMD-7-2546

Organization Contabilizei

Industry Finance and Insurance, Financial Services

Available Languages English

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Entrepreneurship

Business to Business

Digital

Strategy

Browse all topics

Why Chinese companies are betting big on the Euro 24 tournament

By Mark J. Greeven and Howard H. Yu
in I by IMD 5 June 2024

Summary

Leading Chinese companies are preparing to take advantage of exposure and opportunities as top sponsors and suppliers to the UEFA EURO 2024 Men’s S...

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Competitiveness

Innovation

Strategy

China

Future Readiness

Marketing

Browse all topics

A marketing playbook for sustainable products

By Goutam Challagalla and Frédéric Dalsace
in I by IMD 7 May 2024

Summary

Marketing campaigns for sustainable offerings often fail, leaving businesses with products that do not sell. How can companies reach customers more...

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Sustainability

Strategy

Marketing

Browse all topics

How AI gives Taobao's one billion customers the personal touch [Video]

By Amit M. Joshi
in I by IMD 16 April 2024

Summary

Chris Tung is President of Strategic Development at Chinese e-commerce multinational Alibaba Group. He tells Amit Joshi how the company is integrat...

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Artificial Intelligence

Customer Centricity

Marketing

Browse all topics

How Fuchs built a future ready China strategy

By Mark J. Greeven and Wei Wei
Case reference: IMD-7-2543 ©2024

Summary

The case describes the strategic evolution of FUCHS China under the leadership of Zhu Qingping as the company transformed into a vital contributor to the global FUCHS2025 strategy. With 30 years’ experience in the automotive industry, Zhu leveraged his expertise to navigate FUCHS China through the complexities of a rapidly evolving market, amidst geopolitical fragmentation and the challenges posed by Covid-19. FUCHS China, representing a significant portion of the FUCHS Group’s revenue and profits, was at the forefront of adopting innovative product strategies. The case focuses on the development and implementation of the “5S” and “360-degree” solutions. These strategic initiatives enabled FUCHS China to offer specialized, high-tech products (5S) while comprehensively meeting customer needs (360). The case further highlights the company’s market approach, emphasizing the importance of segmentation and the “3L” Localization strategy. This approach not only tailored FUCHS China’s offerings to specific market segments but also enhanced its operational efficiency and responsiveness to local market dynamics. A key element of FUCHS China’s strategy was the development of its team, particularly through the innovative “Huangpu Class” initiative, which focused on nurturing segment leaders and building a robust leadership pipeline. Finally, the case also features FUCHS China’s unique culture, a blend of proactive, performance-driven ethos balanced with German precision and Chinese flexibility. This cultural synthesis was instrumental in fostering a self-driven and adaptable workforce, capable of navigating the challenges and opportunities in China’s lubricant market. Concluding with a forward-looking perspective, the case provides insights into how FUCHS China, under Zhu's visionary leadership, positioned itself as a future-ready player, ready to tackle the upcoming challenges and seize new opportunities in the global lubricant industry.

Reference IMD-7-2543

Organization Fuchs Group

Industry Manufacturing, Chemicals

Available Languages English

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Global Business

China

Business to Business

Browse all topics

How Fuchs drives autonomy at scale to win in a fragmented world

By Mark J. Greeven and Wei Wei
Case reference: IMD-7-2539 ©2024

Summary

In a world where agility and global foresight are crucial for business survival and growth, the FUCHS case presents a compelling narrative of transformation. This case study follows FUCHS, a leading global lubricant company, on its journey to navigate the complexities of a rapidly changing business environment while staying true to its decentralized roots. The story unfolds from the company’s humble beginnings, detailing how FUCHS has grown into a global player under the stewardship of CEO Stefan Fuchs. It emphasizes the challenges of operating in a fragmented market and the need to embrace new global forces, such as digitalization, sustainability and evolving customer expectations. The case highlights the strategic pivot FUCHS makes when it created its first ever corporate strategy, “FUCHS2025,” marking a significant shift in the company’s approach to global market dynamics. A central theme of the case is how FUCHS rethinks its matrix organization and implements agile networks. This strategic move illustrates how FUCHS balances its traditionally decentralized structure with a growing need for global integration and efficiency. The case details the intricacies of these networks, particularly focusing on HR, to show how FUCHS harnesses the power of cross-functional collaboration and shared leadership. Readers of the case will gain a comprehensive understanding of how a traditional, family-led business can successfully adapt to global trends and internal challenges. It’s a tale of strategic evolution, highlighting the delicate balance between maintaining core values and innovating to stay competitive in a fragmented world. The FUCHS case is not just a story of a company, but a blueprint for businesses facing similar global challenges, demonstrating how to win in a decentralized yet interconnected market landscape.

Reference IMD-7-2539

Organization Fuchs Group

Industry Manufacturing, Chemicals

Available Languages English

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

China

Business to Business

Global Business

Strategy

Browse all topics

How to market sustainable products: Three paths to success

By Goutam Challagalla and Frédéric Dalsace
in Harvard Business Review March-April 2024, vol. 102, issue 2, pp. 80-87

Summary

Many companies overestimate customers’ appetite for sustainable products, flooding the market with offerings that don’t sell. The reality is, socia...

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Sustainability

Global Business

Marketing

Browse all topics

Thales: Digital sales enablement with ContentFlix

By Didier Bonnet Michael R. Wade and Lisa Simone Duke
Case reference: IMD-7-2460 ©2024

Summary

The case explores the efforts of Hamilton Mann, Group VP, Global Digital Marketing & Digital Transformation at Thales, to build a sales enablement platform as part of Thales’ larger digital transformation. “ContentFlix” aimed to be a one-stop sales enablement platform bringing together content for presentations and sales pitches and integrating solutions from across the business. Thales’ key account teams were used to operating in silos and via face-to-face interactions. Similarly, marketing and sales were distant and did not work together as effectively and seamlessly as they could. ContentFlix was intended to break down those silos and encourage collaboration between the company’s different businesses and marketing and sales teams. Mann’s team had launched ContentFlix quietly, tackling each implementation challenge as it came, and adoption had been steady. The Covid pandemic changed everything. Enforced lockdowns meant that remote cooperation between units became the only way to do business. The platform’s adoption accelerated beyond Mann’s expectations and continued to grow post-pandemic. The case explores how the team planned the platform, supported its rollout across Thales and continued to build it throughout the pandemic and beyond. The case explores in rich detail the obstacles and challenges as well as the successes Mann and his team face. The case closes with the rise of generative AI (GenAI). The team starts to consider where GenAI could enhance ContentFlix. What possibilities were there to take the platform to its next stage of development?

Reference IMD-7-2460

Organization Thales

Industry Manufacturing;Information Technology, Information Services;Manufacturing, Aerospace and Defense

Available Languages English

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Digital Transformation

Business to Business

Marketing

Strategy

Browse all topics