HomeResearch & Knowledgeback to HomeStrategyback to Research & KnowledgeGrowing pains: Mahindra First Choice 2017back to Strategy

Case Study

Growing pains: Mahindra First Choice 2017

By Charles Dhanaraj, Thomas W. Malnight and Ivy Buche

16 pages

December 2017

Order this case study

Reference: IMD-7-1926

The case focuses on the business and leadership challenges at the intersection of corporate ownership and entrepreneurship. Mahindra and Mahindra Ltd. is the leading utility vehicle manufacturer in India and the largest-selling tractor brand by volume in the world. The company launched its aftermarket business in 1999, and by 2012/13 it had stabilized into two independent companies, each with a CEO who was responsible for growth and profitability. Mahindra First Choice Services (MFCS) focused on providing affordable and reliable servicing for out-of-warranty vehicles, and Mahindra First Choice Wheels (MFCW) focused on creating an ecosystem for used car ownership. Both companies were bold and innovative, and aimed to create new markets to address an unmet need in India’s burgeoning used car industry. However, profits were elusive. Three strategic questions emerged: (1) Should parent Mahindra and Mahindra Ltd. continue to own MFCS and MFCW? (2) Should MFCS and MFCW be combined into a joint entity? (3) What ownership models (company owned, franchise or others) should be adopted to achieve success?

Learning Objective

Corporate ownership: Does corporate ownership help or hurt the growth of entrepreneurial initiatives?
Corporate structure: What are the synergies and benefits of the used car sale/purchase and out-of-warranty service businesses? What are the costs of ownership?
Ownership model: What ownership model(s) should be adopted for high growth and profitability?

Keywords

Strategy, Car, Sales, Services, Value, Entrepreneurship, Company Ownership, Private Equity, Franchise, Business Model, Sustainability, Growth, Profitability, Reduced Inequalities

Settings

Asia, India
Mahindra First Choice, Automotive, Automobiles
2008 - 2017

Type

Field Research

Available Languages

English

IMD case studies are distributed through case clearing houses. In order to browse the collection and purchase copies please visit the links below.

The Case Centre

Cranfield University

Wharley End Beds MK43 0JR, UK
Tel +44 (0)1234 750903
Email [email protected]

Harvard Business School Publishing

60 Harvard Way, Boston MA 02163, USA
Tel (800) 545-7685 Tel (617)-783-7600
Fax (617) 783-7666
Email [email protected]

Asia Pacific Case Center

NUCB Business School

1-3-1 Nishiki Naka
Nagoya Aichi, Japan 460-0003
Tel +81 52 20 38 111
Email [email protected]

IMD retains all proprietary interests in its case studies and notes. Without prior written permission, IMD cases and notes may not be reproduced, used, translated, included in books or other publications, distributed in any form or by any means, stored in a database or in other retrieval systems. For additional copyright information related to case studies, please contact Case Services.

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

2018 JOHN MOLSON MBA CASE WRITING COMPETITION AWARD WINNER

Keep reading

Article

5 Things to Know - Energy Transition - 2025

Despite policy and market headwinds, the clean energy transition is accelerating. Here are five key insights business leaders need to know in 2025.

Sustainability

By Knut Haanaes and Jad Mouawad

in I by IMD

Article

Climate Risk - CFO Horizons - Financial Imperative

CFOs must drive a financially disciplined way to manage environmental and climate risk amid growing push back against sustainability efforts.

Finance Sustainability

By Karl Schmedders

in I by IMD

Podcast

How does sustainable leadership work?

This episode takes you behind the scenes of a recent gathering led by the World Business Council for Sustainable Development together with IMD, where David Bach sat down with two sustainability leaders.

Leadership Sustainability

By David Bach and Felix Zeltner

in I by IMD

Article

Repairing reputational damage: don’t go the way of Boeing

All organizations should have a plan to secure trust during, after (and even before) a crisis hits. Here are a host of examples, good and bad, to learn from.

Leadership Resilience Strategy

By Michael Skapinker

in I by IMD

Case Study

The price of innovation: Will Medacta compromise its DNA by embracing robotics?

Strategy Innovation

By Carlos Cordon, Antonio Di Brino, Jesper Fibiger, Frank Kristensen, Soniya Soniya and Alison End Fineberg

Article

Efficient Green Transition - 4 Effective Strategies

Discover four proven strategies for sustainable and efficient green transition. Split operations with ring fencing to fast-track your green goals.

Sustainability

By Salvatore Cantale and Frederikke Due Olsen

in I by IMD

Article

Strategy Meets Execution - Supply Chain

10 years of exclusive surveys reveal top supply chain strategy challenges—and how tools like AI, ML, and digital twins are reshaping the path forward.

Strategy Supply Chain

By Ralf W. Seifert and Katrin Siebenbürger Hacki

in I by IMD

Article

4 Key Guidelines for Success - Demystifying AI Use Cases

Uncover AI use cases and opportunities with 4 clear imperatives that align data with business value. Avoid pitfalls and ask the right questions.

Artificial Intelligence Strategy

By Didier Bonnet and Achim Plueckebaum

in I by IMD

Podcast

Can biodiversity credits alter the landscape for nature conservation?

Join IMD Senior Researcher Adrian Dellecker and Mariana Sarmiento of Terrasos to explore business opportunities in voluntary biodiversity credits and environmental innovation.

Business Transformation Innovation Sustainability

By Adrian Dellecker

in I by IMD

Podcast

Can eDNA revolutionize biodiversity monitoring?

Explore eDNA science with Kristy Deiner on the IMD Management Cast . Learn how genetics, biodiversity, and data analytics shape conservation and the bioeconomy.

Innovation Sustainability Technology Management Value Creation

By Adrian Dellecker

in I by IMD

Repairing reputational damage: don’t go the way of Boeing

By Michael Skapinker
in I by IMD

Summary

All organizations should have a plan to secure trust during, after (and even before) a crisis hits. Here are a host of examples, good and bad, to learn from.

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Leadership

Resilience

Strategy

Browse all topics

The price of innovation: Will Medacta compromise its DNA by embracing robotics?

By Carlos Cordon Antonio Di Brino Jesper Fibiger Frank Kristensen Soniya Soniya and Alison End Fineberg
Case reference: IMD-2663 ©2025

Summary

Medacta Group SA is a rising star in the orthopedics market, achieving global success through innovative products and techniques, with a particular emphasis on minimally invasive techniques that bring meaningful value to its patients. With its approaches such as Anterior Minimally Invasive Surgery (AMIS) for hip replacement and Kinematic Alignment for knees, Medacta offers high-quality techniques, supporting tools and cutting-edge implants. It also offers personalized surgeon education through the Medacta Orthopedic Research and Education (M.O.R.E.) Institute. Medacta is situated in an evolving landscape, with competitors including Stryker and Zimmer Biomet investing heavily in robotic technologies. Technological advances are being made in data-driven planning tools – including augmented reality – and research institutes are looking for the most advanced solutions as demanded by many hospitals and surgeons. Despite these trends in the industry, Medacta's CEO, Francesco Siccardi has concerns regarding the value of existing robotic systems, noting their lack of proven benefits in patient outcomes or cost reductions, especially in a context of increasing emphasis on value-based care and sustainability. The case explores the opportunities and challenges confronting Medacta as they decide whether to enter the orthopedic robotics market. The company wants to continue to differentiate itself and drive growth in line with its foundational principles of patient care, operational excellence and sustainable innovation. Today, Francesco faces a critical decision around whether now is the time to enter the robotics market and, if so, how Medacta should do so to preserve its culture and stay true to its DNA.

Reference IMD-2663

Organization Medacta Group

Industry Healthcare, Medical Device

Available Languages English

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Strategy

Innovation

Browse all topics

Can biodiversity credits alter the landscape for nature conservation?

By Adrian Dellecker
in I by IMD

Summary

Join IMD Senior Researcher Adrian Dellecker and Mariana Sarmiento of Terrasos to explore business opportunities in voluntary biodiversity credits and environmental innovation.

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Business Transformation

Innovation

Sustainability

Browse all topics

Can eDNA revolutionize biodiversity monitoring?

By Adrian Dellecker
in I by IMD

Summary

Explore eDNA science with Kristy Deiner on the IMD Management Cast . Learn how genetics, biodiversity, and data analytics shape conservation and the bioeconomy.

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Innovation

Sustainability

Technology Management

Value Creation

Browse all topics