HomeResearch & Knowledgeback to HomeOrganizational Behaviorback to Research & KnowledgePlaying to win: Leadership and sustainability at ESB Electric Utilityback to Organizational Behavior

Case Study

Playing to win: Leadership and sustainability at ESB Electric Utility

By George Kohlrieser, Sophie Linguri Coughlan and Francisco Szekely

20 pages

July 2010

Order this case study

Reference: IMD-4-0302

In 2007, the Irish electric utility, Electricity Supply Board (ESB) – 95% publicly owned-, contributed 15% of Ireland’s greenhouse gas emissions. It owned the largest point sources of the country’s rising carbon dioxide emissions. Due to extraordinary economic development, Ireland’s greenhouse gases emissions were continually rising. The situation was clearly untenable. In March 2008, ESB’s chief executive Padraig McManus made the startling announcement that the company would become a net-zero carbon emitter by 2035, and would still remain competitive. Under his leadership, ESB was going to lead the way in slowing the growth of Ireland’s GHG emissions. He declared that to achieve this goal, ESB would invest €22 billion over 15 years to develop alternative clean technologies, including energy efficiency measures, the use of clean coal, and the connection of an electricity-generating wind farm to the national grid. His target would make ESB the world’s first carbon-neutral electric utility. This strategy presented a number of significant risks: 1) Financial risk – the €22 billion capital investment had to succeed. 2) Technological and ecological risks – the strategic framework relied on clean coal technology, still being developed. 3) Credibility risk – what if ESB was not able to achieve its goal? 4) Stakeholder risk – Landowners, concerned over health, environment and property prices, were ready to oppose the wind farms. McManus was conscious of the risks, and he also knew that high performing leaders always take risks even while confronting dilemmas such as: Could an electric utility achieve a zero carbon footprint and remain competitive? Can a responsible leader risk jeopardizing the present and future well-being of his company, the environment, and his country? Could he exert his leadership by influencing Irish, and possibly European, climate policy? The case provides an opportunity for a debate on responsible leadership. It was written for use in senior executive and MBA programs.

Learning Objective

1) How can responsible leaders balance the competing pressures for economic performance, ecological protection and social responsibility and continue growing the business? 2) What kinds of risks can responsible leaders undertake? 3) How can responsible leaders create value for their shareholders and stakeholders? 4) Can the leader of small European electric utility influence the entire European electric utility sector?

Keywords

High Performance Leadership, Social Responsibility, Energy

Settings

Republic of Ireland
Electricity Supply Board, Energy, Power Generation
2007-2010

Type

Field Research

Available Languages

English

Related material

Teaching note

IMD retains all proprietary interests in its case studies and notes. Without prior written permission, IMD cases and notes may not be reproduced, used, translated, included in books or other publications, distributed in any form or by any means, stored in a database or in other retrieval systems. For additional copyright information related to case studies, please contact Case Services.

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

This case study is part of a series

Playing to win: Leadership and sustainability at ESB Electric Utility
Playing to win: Leadership and sustainability at ESB Electric Utility

2011 ECCH AWARD WINNER (Hot Topic: Renewable & Sustainable Energy, Technology & Development)

This case study is part of a series

Playing to win: Leadership and sustainability at ESB Electric Utility
Playing to win: Leadership and sustainability at ESB Electric Utility

Playing to win: Leadership and sustainability at ESB Electric Utility

By George Kohlrieser Sophie Linguri Coughlan and Francisco Szekely
Case reference: IMD-4-0302 ©2010

Summary

In 2007, the Irish electric utility, Electricity Supply Board (ESB) – 95% publicly owned-, contributed 15% of Ireland’s greenhouse gas emissions. I...

2011 ECCH AWARD WINNER (Hot Topic: Renewable & Sustainable Energy, Technology & Development)

Reference IMD-4-0302

Organization Electricity Supply Board

Industry Energy, Power Generation

Available Languages English

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Organizational Behavior

Browse all topics

Playing to win: Leadership and sustainability at ESB Electric Utility

By George Kohlrieser Sophie Linguri Coughlan and Francisco Szekely
Case reference: IMD-4-0302 ©2010

Summary

In 2007, the Irish electric utility, Electricity Supply Board (ESB) – 95% publicly owned-, contributed 15% of Ireland’s greenhouse gas emissions. I...

2011 ECCH AWARD WINNER (Hot Topic: Renewable & Sustainable Energy, Technology & Development)

Reference IMD-4-0302

Organization Electricity Supply Board

Industry Energy, Power Generation

Available Languages English

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Organizational Behavior

Browse all topics

Keep reading

Case Study

Governance at WeWork: Adam Neumann’s erratic behavior

This is a fascinating case about Adam Neumann’s problematic behavior, which led to the downfall of WeWork, once one of America’s most valued startu...

Board Organizational Behavior Diversity and Equity and Inclusion Organizational Culture

By Anand Narasimhan and Shruti Bajpai

Article

Six signs of a parent-child dynamic at the office

For managers and teams, this is an unhealthy rapport. Here’s how to stop rolling your eyes and start treating each other like full-fledged adults. ...

Organizational Behavior Team Dynamics Talent Management

By Jennifer Jordan

in MIT Sloan Management Review Blog

17 June 2024

Case Study

Civilia Engineering: Cultivating value through a data-driven culture

No company can grasp the potential of AI until it has set up a data-driven culture enabling employees to create value from the insights that emerge...

Disruption Organizational Behavior Strategy

By José Parra Moyano and Lisa Simone Duke

Case Study

Human error, crisis management and business continuity: Flight KE007

In 1983, Korean Air Lines Flight KE007, a Boeing 747, suffered a tragic fate that claimed the lives of all 269 passengers and crew. Against the bac...

General Management Leadership Organizational Behavior Geopolitics Crisis Management

By Sameh Abadir and Marc Chauvet

Case Study

Has Elon Musk X’d out?

In 2022, Elon Musk, known for his innovative ideas and often compared to Steve Jobs, made a big move by buying Twitter for $44 billion. He then sta...

Strategy Digital Transformation Entrepreneurship General Management Leadership Organizational Behavior

By Stefan Michel and Kathe Sweeney

Case Study

STADA: Sustaining agility and entrepreneurship in a fast-growing pharma company

Peter Goldschmidt became the CEO of pharmaceuticals company STADA in 2018. He was a firm believer in culture as a driving force – and a predictor –...

Organizational Behavior Entrepreneurship Human Resources Leadership

By John R. Weeks and Martin Králik

Case Study

The physics of leadership: Mobilizing, focusing and sustaining leadership in your organization

This note uses physics metaphors like energy and momentum as a framework for leaders to drive success in their organizations. Effective leaders mob...

Communication Digital General Management Human Resources Leadership Organizational Behavior

By Michael D. Watkins

Article

Lessons in change from a global pandemic

Perhaps the most obvious impact of the pandemic on our expectations of change was that for many observers—both academics and leaders—the speed with...

Disruption Organizational Learning Global Business Organizational Behavior

By Shlomo Ben-Hur

in Thinkers50 Blog

December 2023

Article

In the field with Roche: Can a 100,000-strong global workforce embrace autonomy and self-leadership to become more empowered, adaptable and agile?

Can a 100,000-strong global workforce embrace autonomy and self-leadership to become more empowered, adaptable and agile?

Disruption Human Resources Leadership Organizational Behavior Organizational Culture

By Louise Muhdi and Martin Králik

in In the Field

December 2023

Case Study

Retaining entrepreneurial spirit during hypergrowth at sportswear brand On (B)

When one of On’s co-founders stepped into the elevator at the brand new On Labs headquarters in Zurich, a fellow co-worker asked whether it was als...

Entrepreneurship Human Resources Leadership Organizational Behavior

By Alyson Meister and Valerie Keller-Birrer

Governance at WeWork: Adam Neumann’s erratic behavior

By Anand Narasimhan and Shruti Bajpai
Case reference: IMD-7-2591 ©2024

Summary

This is a fascinating case about Adam Neumann’s problematic behavior, which led to the downfall of WeWork, once one of America’s most valued startups.

Reference IMD-7-2591

Organization The We Company

Industry Services, Real Estate

Available Languages English

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Board

Organizational Behavior

Diversity and Equity and Inclusion

Organizational Culture

Browse all topics

Six signs of a parent-child dynamic at the office

By Jennifer Jordan
in MIT Sloan Management Review Blog 17 June 2024

Summary

For managers and teams, this is an unhealthy rapport. Here’s how to stop rolling your eyes and start treating each other like full-fledged adults. ...

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Organizational Behavior

Team Dynamics

Talent Management

Browse all topics

Civilia Engineering: Cultivating value through a data-driven culture

By José Parra Moyano and Lisa Simone Duke
Case reference: IMD-7-2548 ©2024

Summary

No company can grasp the potential of AI until it has set up a data-driven culture enabling employees to create value from the insights that emerge from data analysis. This means that before setting up an AI strategy, organizations must transform and prepare their infrastructure and culture for the AI age. This case study discusses the initiatives developed and rolled out by Marianne Galvin, initially Head of Data Office and then VP of Digital Transformation, as she worked to turn Civilia Engineering into a data-driven company. The case explores what Marianne put in place over her first 22 months with the company. This included: Governance structures and an educational program that proved to be highly popular. As the initiatives took root, Marianne and her team began to gain acceptance of use cases and dashboards for data-driven decision making but there were still several challenges to overcome, in particular how to work with an IT team more focused on architecture and improving legacy systems. The case closes as Marianne looks ahead to 2024, outlining what still needs to be done to gain digital and data maturity. The case provides a comprehensive understanding of the critical aspects of building a data-driven organization, particularly focusing on the interplay between value, data, and people. Through this case, learners will develop a nuanced understanding of the three pillars that sustain data-driven organizations, how to create a data-centric culture, how to avoid pitfalls in data-science projects and the nuances of digital transformation in non-digital organizations. They will be equipped with the knowledge and skills necessary to effectively lead and contribute to the building of data-driven organizations, fostering an environment that embraces data-centric decision-making and successfully navigates the complexities of digital transformation in an increasingly data-driven world.

Reference IMD-7-2548

Organization Civilia Engineering (Disguised)

Industry Construction and Engineering, Civil Engineering

Available Languages English

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Disruption

Organizational Behavior

Strategy

Browse all topics

Human error, crisis management and business continuity: Flight KE007

By Sameh Abadir and Marc Chauvet
Case reference: IMD-7-2551 ©2024

Summary

In 1983, Korean Air Lines Flight KE007, a Boeing 747, suffered a tragic fate that claimed the lives of all 269 passengers and crew. Against the backdrop of Cold War tensions, the aircraft experienced an autopilot failure and veered significantly off course into Soviet airspace. The crew’s missteps led to a series of misinterpretations because there was a lack of awareness of geopolitical intricacies and technological constraints. Confusion was triggered as a result of Flight KE007 entering Soviet territory during a heightened state of alert for a missile test, miscommunications, and a malfunctioning radar system. Soviet fighter jets, unable to establish communication, fired warning shots. When Flight KE007 sought altitude clearance, in accordance with its flight plan, this maneuver was misread as evasion and the Soviet military launched a missile that downed the aircraft. Post-incident, the Soviets maintained secrecy, attributing the intrusion to ongoing provocations. However, this catastrophe was the catalyst for pivotal advancements in air safety. The Reagan administration pledged to introduce GPS for civil aviation by 1988, which would afford precise global positioning. Interim measures included the extension of US military radar coverage and the establishment of a joint air traffic control system in 1986, with the Soviet Union monitoring civilian air traffic over the North Pacific. The narrative unfolds at the intersection of aviation, politics and global security in the early 1980s. Beyond technical and human factors, it underscores the profound impact of international relations and the subsequent strides in air safety emerging from this poignant chapter in aviation history.

Reference IMD-7-2551

Organization Korean Airlines

Industry Travel and Leisure, Airlines and Aviation

Available Languages English

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

General Management

Leadership

Organizational Behavior

Geopolitics

Crisis Management

Browse all topics

Has Elon Musk X’d out?

By Stefan Michel and Kathe Sweeney
Case reference: IMD-7-2537 ©2024

Summary

In 2022, Elon Musk, known for his innovative ideas and often compared to Steve Jobs, made a big move by buying Twitter for $44 billion. He then sta...

Reference IMD-7-2537

Organization X (Former Twitter)

Industry Social Media

Available Languages English

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Strategy

Digital Transformation

Entrepreneurship

General Management

Leadership

Organizational Behavior

Browse all topics

STADA: Sustaining agility and entrepreneurship in a fast-growing pharma company

By John R. Weeks and Martin Králik
Case reference: IMD-7-2453 ©2024

Summary

Peter Goldschmidt became the CEO of pharmaceuticals company STADA in 2018. He was a firm believer in culture as a driving force – and a predictor – of organizational performance and competitiveness. A year earlier, two private equity funds had become majority owners of the “old” STADA – essentially a loose, decentralized network of country operations. After taking the helm, Goldschmidt made building a growth culture one of the strategic pillars aimed at transforming the company into a leader in consumer health, global generics and specialty pharma. As a major lever to achieve that vision, the CEO put forward four core values to define the new, aspirational brand of STADA’s culture: agility, entrepreneurship, integrity and “one STADA.” In its quest for agility, resilience and speed, STADA’s leadership recognized the need for an ambitious transformation that would improve collaboration to leverage learning, talent and technology, while centralizing some processes and reducing duplication and waste. Amid the Covid pandemic, in March 2020, STADA reported the highest production output in the group’s 125-year history. By 2022, the company was well on its way to achieving the owners’ growth objectives of becoming a strong, well-run organization. In a short span of five years, between 2018 and 2023, STADA built a platform that should allow the business to scale to five times its current size.

Reference IMD-7-2453

Organization Stada Arzneimittel

Industry Healthcare, Pharmaceuticals

Available Languages English

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Organizational Behavior

Entrepreneurship

Human Resources

Leadership

Browse all topics

The physics of leadership: Mobilizing, focusing and sustaining leadership in your organization

By Michael D. Watkins
Case reference: IMD-7-2511 ©2023

Summary

This note uses physics metaphors like energy and momentum as a framework for leaders to drive success in their organizations. Effective leaders mob...

Reference IMD-7-2511

Available Languages English

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Communication

Digital

General Management

Human Resources

Leadership

Organizational Behavior

Browse all topics

Lessons in change from a global pandemic

By Shlomo Ben-Hur
in Thinkers50 Blog December 2023

Summary

Perhaps the most obvious impact of the pandemic on our expectations of change was that for many observers—both academics and leaders—the speed with...

Contact

Research Information & Knowledge Hub for additional information on IMD publications

Related topics

Disruption

Organizational Learning

Global Business

Organizational Behavior

Browse all topics